
I meant to post
about this earlier but it has been in my saved drafts for a long time because I
kept adding to it as I learned more about the Talibé. Also all these pictures are from the internet because I didn't feel comfortable taking pictures of them
while I was there.
The word Talibé
means “student,” but in English, the word has a connotation to mean a student
that studies Islam. You see them running around all over the streets of Dakar, usually barefoot and in dirty clothes asking for food and money as a part of their curriculum. Parents send their kids to Marabouts (religious leaders/teachers in West Africa) veto schools called Daaras (Quranic schools, usually at the home of a Marabout and not usually a part of the formal education system) because they
believe that it is an opportunity for them to have a Quranic education for
free, and often these families don't have the means to send their kids to public school. Usually these kids live with the Marabout and learn the Quran until they are about 15 years old, in exchange for a
small quota that they have to beg for in the streets and then give to the Marabout.
With my education
class, we went to visit one of the daaras in Dakar and talk to the marabout (asked questions which were then translated into Wolof).
There was a big room that was used for studying the Quran, for
prayer, and sleeping - apparently all of the children slept on the floor on these mats, no
mosquito nets or beds. There were stray cats running in and out, and it didn't
seem like a very clean place to live. The Marabout talked about how this was one
of the better daaras, and how you can't really get look at one daara and assume
they are all like it because the conditions vary from daara to daara. He said
that in that daara, he never beat the kids, and that he only required that the
students bring him a minimum of 300 CFA (maybe 75 cents) per day, and the rest
they can keep for themselves.
Its hard to improve the conditions of the lives of the Talibé because of poverty, and the power that marabouts have in Senegalese society. The government and other international organizations have tried to help improve the conditions of the Talibé, but the system of the Talibé and Marabout are so engrained in Senegalese culture that it's not easy to change. Also Marabouts are viewed as some of the most important people in Senegal and have tons of economic and political power in the society.
As an American coming to Senegal and seeing the Talibé all over the street, I couldn't help but feel a lot of sadness for them. I can't imagine spending my childhood begging in the streets. But in Senegal and for many Muslims, they view this traditional education as sort of necessary passage into adulthood, and Talibé are often proud to be part of this tradition. I talked to my host Mom about this and she was telling me about how for many Muslims, being able to give to the Talibé is something that gives them a sense of being a good Muslim. Whenever we had leftovers in my host family, we always saved it to give it to the Talibé. We had a few regulars that would come by the house in the evening and ask for something to eat too, and my family would expect them. Muslims give to the Talibé in the morning because they believe that it will bring them more luck during the day. My host Dad was also telling me that the Talibé from all over West Africa come to Senegal because they know this about Senegalese people. They know that Senegalese people love to give and while this is good, it also means that this kind of justifies the problem and makes it so that there are way too many of them concentrated in places like Dakar.
One of the five pillars of Islam, Zakat, says you must help people who are in need who don’t have the means to help themselves. Also, Islam requires Muslims to study the Quran and to know God, which is why there are so many marabous and Quranic schools in Senegal. The daaras are a way that people can give their kids at least a religious education if they aren't able to send their kids to a french or private school. While it's good to give to the Talibé, even if you gave them clothes and food every day it doesn't help the long term problem or the fact that they are still living in poverty. When you do give them a new shirt or shoes, it usually gets taken by another older Talibé in the Daaras.
The main problem with the daaras right now is that they aren't regulated. There has been talk about the need to regulate them and make sure there are at least some minimum standards like access to clean water, sanitation, mosquito nets, food, toilets, basic health care, etc. but there has not been much action taken. Most of the daaras don't provide very comfortable living conditions, and many the Talibé don’t have access to water or electricity, and sleep together on the floor in rooms without mosquito nets. There have also been reports of abuse on the part of the Marabout.
Another big problem right now is that a lot of Marabouts often take advantage of the Talibé and exploit them to make a profit. Usually the money that the Talibé bring in from the streets isn't put towards the kids well being or is not used to help support them, but the Marabout just keeps it all for himself. I got the impression that the daaras have changed a lot over time in history, and it used to be a smaller tradition in villages. But now, Taliban have to spend a huge part of their day in the street and it didn't used to be this way.
There are around ten thousand Talibé in Dakar. If the Talibé aren't successful at bringing back the minimum quota required by the Marabout, they are sometimes beaten. The Marabouts sometimes make more money with their children then if they were to have a real job. This creates thousands of children that are malnourished, dirty, barefoot and prone to sickness, running around the streets of Dakar searching for enough money so that they don't get beaten when they get back to the house of the marabout. In the city, the Marabouts are much less confronted with social pressure than in the villages. Some of them even have more than one daara and make money off of their kids, hiding the truth from their parents.
The Quranic schools that are part of the recognized education system are not the same as the daaras - the Quranic schools are recognized by the formal education system. In the Quranic schools, the Quran is taught along with Arabic, but usually French is also taught, along with other subjects like math, science, etc. This is generally seen as a better option because if they decide to get a job later in life they might have more options available. The downside though is that usually these schools that offer both a religious education and a colonial education can be expensive.
 |
Modern Daara |
I think that one of the things that could be to help the problem would be to add the daaras to the formal education system, because if they were part of it then it would be ensured that the students were actually getting their education in the daaras, and not just becoming subject to begging in the streets. The state also needs to look out for the kids to see if they are abused or not, and ensure that they have enough to eat, access to proper water, and are not exploited by the marabous. It's also an issue that pretty much anyone can just open up a daara and pretend to be a marabou, and take in Talibé to use them to make a profit since they aren't regulated. It is an issue that is not well addressed, and the state does not want to ban it because it is a matter of religion.
The government could restore human rights in the daaras if they decided to, but it is complicated when politics and religion become mixed. What is needed is for people to start seeing this as a human rights issue, and not a matter of maintaining religious schools. Religious schools can still exist but it seems to me that there is no reason why they need to be in such conditions, where children have to go out and get exploited by marabouts, or be in such poverish conditions. Human Rights Watch also has been saying for years that Senegal needs to create stricter laws for daaras. These boys don’t have much of a future if they spend most of their childhoods on the street begging. But unfortunately the government is not putting this issue at the top of their list of priorities.